All sixteen traditions

Tianxia

Confucianism

All under heaven, joined by relationships that make people fully human.

The idea

Ren, humaneness, is not a private virtue. It exists in relationships. Nobody becomes fully human alone.

What Confucianism has built

Confucian thought grounds human development in the cultivation of right relationships: parent and child, teacher and student, ruler and subject, friend and friend. Ren is something that lives between people, in the quality of how they meet. The self is made by its relationships and does not exist before them.

The Confucian picture of civilisation is a set of widening circles, from family to community to state to tianxia, all under heaven. Tianxia is the horizon: a world in which right relationship has been extended to every person.

Where it already reaches further

The tradition has a detailed account of what makes a relationship produce good thinking and good action. The question it has always faced is what practice could carry that quality of relationship to the scale of a civilisation.

Confucius drew the distinction this project depends on:

“The noble person seeks harmony, not sameness. The petty person seeks sameness, not harmony.”

Confucius, Analects 13.23, our translation

Harmony without sameness is what a meeting between traditions needs: people who stay fully different and still work well together.

Where it stops

If the self is made by relationships, then the quality of a group’s thinking depends on the quality of the relationships it thinks through. Confucian thought knows a great deal about this among people who share a culture. What would its principles look like when the people in relationship do not share a culture, or even a way of knowing?