The field

Case study · EU Horizon

Europe has engineered collaboration since 1984. Getting disciplines to truly integrate is still its hardest problem.

Nine generations of research programmes have refined how teams form across countries. Their own evaluations show where the method stops.

  • Horizon Europe, 2021 to 2027
  • €95.5 billion
  • Science and innovation

The story

CERN and the International Space Station grew out of political circumstances. Europe’s research framework programmes were designed from the beginning to produce collaboration across borders. Horizon Europe is the ninth generation. Since 1984 each round has refined how research teams are formed across countries, how money is shared, how results are measured and what to change next time.

Funded projects must include partners from at least three countries, and the programme rewards teams that cross disciplines. Its missions, on climate adaptation, cancer, oceans, cities and soil, are built as problems no single discipline can solve. Recent rounds have begun to bring in the social sciences and humanities, and in some new frameworks traditional knowledge.

The programme’s evaluations are candid about what it has not achieved. Getting disciplines to integrate, as opposed to sitting side by side in one project, remains hard to produce and hard to measure. The friction between academic and applied knowledge, and between formal science and local knowledge, has not gone away.

What it shows

Collaboration can be engineered, and nine generations of trying have built up real knowledge about what helps and what gets in the way. That knowledge is some of the most useful available to anyone designing a new system.

Where it stops

Horizon is bounded by geography (mostly Europe), by sector (mostly science and technology) and by culture (mostly academic). Contemplative, indigenous and artistic ways of knowing sit at the edge of its design.

More important, it is a system for funding and rewarding collaboration. It does nothing to build people’s ability to work across real difference. The evaluation evidence is Europe’s own. The reading that follows is ours: the obstacle that keeps showing up is not money or incentives, but the inner capacity of the people involved to hold deep difference without collapsing it.

What it means for us

If our reading is right, a better funding design will not solve this. What is missing is human capacity, and the conditions that let people use it. That is where we are working. We see Horizon and WhatIfWe as working on different levels of the same problem, and an infrastructure like ours would need what Horizon has learned.